A Defense of Twilight

Yes, you read that right.

I’m sure I’m not the first to have written something like this, particularly since it’s well past prime time for Twilight…anything. The wave of wild appreciation for the novels passed long ago, as did the quick-to-follow wave of derision. But it’s something that I think is actually quite important, as a writer and as a human. Important enough to sit down a write a spiel about a decade later. Important enough that I must first give you some of my personal history with Twilight.

Allow me to set the scene:

It is 2007. I am sitting on a charter bus that is swaying its way across the west American desert to the general area of Anaheim, California, where my high school choir will be singing for about 15% of the time and engaging in all manner of (mostly innocent) teenage degeneracy at Disneyland for the other 85%. Sitting beside me is one of my friends, a book in her hands, her being entirely captivated by the words on the page. The cover art is compellingly simple, a solid design. I’ve seen it before, numerous times and in numerous hands; I ask what the book is about. My friend hands me the book to read the synopsis.

Twilight

I wasn’t particularly interested, then. It sounded “girly” and at this time in my life I took great pride in not being “girly,” which is a whole separate topic for another day. And, setting my disappointing aversion to stereotypically female things aside, I tended to prefer older and more fantastical settings in my novels. So a year or two passed before I thought of the Twilight books again.

Somehow my family acquired copies of the first few books and brought them on a family trip to Yellowstone. My mom, brother, and I each read all of the available books within that 4-5 day trip while my dad, presumably, wondered what the big deal was. (I think he tried to read them and gave up after the first couple of pages. Haha.) I was as drawn into the books as everyone else seemed to have been, as much as my friend on the bus had been that day in 2007. Suddenly I was part of their popularity, buying the final books the day they were released and discussing the story and characters with my friends.

And then…the backlash. Suddenly the books were a stain on literacy. No one would admit to ever having liked them. The grammar was ripped apart, the questionable ethics of Edward and Bella’s relationship were illuminated and decried, the interpretation of vampires became an offense to mythology, and those brave enough to stand by their beloved book series were mocked as stupid teenagers or horny house wives. And I admit—I joined in. Not in mocking people for liking something (that’s rude, guys), but I did make fun of the novels. I saw the poor grammar, the purposefully bland character of Bella, the stalker-but-it’s-okay-because-she-likes-it character of Edward, and I acquired the same ruthless contempt for the books that so many around me adopted.

Twilight 1

But here’s the thing: I read the books again, very recently. I read them knowing that it’s not my genre, that the grammar was pretty shoddy, that the novel’s romance was dubious and controversial, and that my opinion of the book was probably the most unforgiving of any book I’d ever read. And I couldn’t put it down. I was hooked—again! All that other stuff didn’t matter. And that’s when I realized that for as much hate as Stephanie Meyer got for these books she’d tapped into something that created a phenomenon, and there was something there that would teach me about writing.

This book has a relatable main character, whether you think so or not.

Twilight 2

So many women enjoyed reading this book because Bella is…shall we say…versatile. She has very few defining personality traits, which is often pointed out as a huge flaw of the book (and I would agree.) But she does have several very understandable interests and motivations. She wants to be seen as something special—so do most of us. She would make great sacrifices for love—so would many of us. Many times Bella feels underqualified for her situation—too normal, too ordinary.  I don’t know about you, but that feels very familiar.

If you are a writer, I wouldn’t recommend doing this the “Bella” way. Good characters feel like fully finished people, with their own interests and quirks and faults that make them unique. But Stephanie Meyer did a good enough job with the other stuff—the external things that we can all understand and relate to—that it was wildly successful anyway. That’s pretty impressive, when you think about it.

It got people to read. 

Twilight 3

This really needs no explanation. Twilight was one of the most successful book series of all time, and it brought hundreds of previous non-readers into the world of words and imagination. I think that’s worth something, don’t you?

The mockery of Twilight fans and their interests is frequently rooted in sexism. 

Twilight 4

Yeah…here’s where my feminist side struts on out to present my unsolicited hot take. But honestly, the interests of teenage girls and stay-at-home moms are constantly, constantly made fun of by anyone who doesn’t fall into these categories, and often by people who do (see paragraph about young Tara above). Music, hobbies, fashion and, of course, books, that are latched on to by these groups are widely considered to be silly, or frivolous, or stupid, or any manner of unflattering adjectives. In my (probably biased but still valuable) opinion, a series as wildly popular as Twilight was would never have received the extreme and near-immediate backlash that it did if it weren’t so popular among female audiences. Isn’t that sad? I’m not saying that if you made fun of this book or its readers that you are definitely sexist, by the way, but it is a thing and worth considering. This series got people to read and made those oft-mocked readers feel special and interesting as they stepped into Bella’s shoes…maybe that’s not really super cool to make fun of, in the end.

This whole rant/essay isn’t here to change anyone’s opinion about the books. They’re definitely not for everyone, and you don’t have to think they’re good. But if you’re someone who, like me, used to wonder why so many people loved this “trash,” well…like they say, sometimes these things are more treasure than we think. Perhaps it’s better to wonder what we can learn from it instead.

Happy reading, friends!

sig

Advertisements

5 Comments

  1. I dig this post, Tara! When this series was doing the rounds in high school (*everybody* seemed to be reading it) I borrowed a copy from a friend for the weekend. It’s very ‘readable’, in the sense that you can read it quite fast, but it didn’t captivate me the way it did so many others. I cringed countless times, desperate to edit certain parts because I felt like there was a good story somewhere in those pages, and decided not to read the rest of the books. Having said that, if I draw the parallel to movies and TV shows, my palate is more forgiving – I have watched so many ‘trashy’, ‘girly’ shows, devoured hours upon hours of them, and I think it hits the same nerve, and it *does* make me stop and pause and think I can learn from them. And keeping with this parallel, I can’t help but feel you might be onto something with that last point – after all, how many terrible ‘action movies’ out there are acknowledged as terrible but forgiven rather than ripped to shreds; is it any coincidence that that genre is considered more of a ‘guy thing’? Hmmm.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thank you! I love your point about other media—I agree that you could easily compare those kinds of shows. Some things you just enjoy and it doesn’t always make sense! haha. But anything as popular as Twilight or those “trashy” shows has tapped into something vital about entertainment that can teach us some key things about creating our own content. And yes, 100% agree with your comment on “masculine” media! So many movies and shows are problematic or just terrible but are either shrugged off and forgotten, or looked at fondly despite the flaws, because they are aimed at a male audience. Somehow a male audience lends more legitimacy, regardless of the quality. It’s a bummer.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Great post! Thanks so much for writing this!

    Actually, to be honest, I have never been able to make fun of the Twilight series at all in my life. Such was my attraction to the story.

    I mean, I did understand how people could see some of the loopholes in it, but which story is perfect? Nothing on this planet is perfect.

    Like

    1. Thank you! And I’m so glad you’ve stood by Twilight. I spent way too many years in the past questioning and abandoning the hobbies and stories I loved just because other people didn’t like them—so silly of me! I like to think I’ve grown since then and have learned to stick with my own opinions. You are so right, nothing is perfect!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s